Familiar box removed too fast
The redesign failed because the new mark did not explain what buyer memory should carry forward.
Branding guide · Logo redesign examples
The point is not whether the new logo is cleaner. The useful question is what recognition asset is protected, what buyers have to relearn, and where the new mark has to work before the launch is safe.
recognition · surface · memory · risk

Read each example by what changed, what stayed, and where recognition was protected or lost.
The redesign failed because the new mark did not explain what buyer memory should carry forward.
The circles stayed strong enough for the wordmark to step back in some contexts.
The mark could not carry belonging unless the marketplace experience made the promise believable.
The arrow works because it supports the delivery promise instead of replacing it.
The mark can stay spare because the product and retail system keep teaching the cue.
The mark is simple, but it is reinforced by performance surfaces and athlete memory.
The box and color do recognition work before the wordmark needs to explain anything.
A refresh can work when the product category stays easy to recognize.
Do not score a logo change in isolation. Score the cue system.
If a name, color, mark, message, voice, or page is starting to affect sales or trust, get the public-facing decision checked before rollout makes it harder to change.